I needed to write a blog post. Then I got distracted by Facebook. This is the result...
I’ve been reading a bunch of articles lately that have
gotten me a bit conflicted and, because I’m conflicted, this post has the
potential to be kinda’ rough. Bear with me. Or don’t. Whatever you want is
fine. I would love to hear thoughts though if you do stick around. (otherwise
skip ahead. There’s pictures at the bottom. insert winking emoji)
It started with a couple of facebook posts regarding an
Instagram account for White Savior Barbie. I guess a couple of young ladies
working in east Africa started using Barbie to make tongue-in-cheek social
critiques of missions, specifically short term “voluntourism”, from the “west
to the rest” kinda stuff.
You know how facebook does that thing where when you click
on a link it suggests others you might be interested in? Well, I got stuck in
one of those loops and spent way too much time reading article after article
that mostly just made me feel guilty for being who I am, in the place that I
am. There was one from a journalist who’s spent a bunch of time in the
developing world commenting on western “voluntourists” building a school while
unemployed local masons stand around watching. There was one from The Onion
titled “6-Day Visit to Rural African Village completely Changes Woman’s
Facebook Profile Picture”. This is an especially funny one about the life
changing facebook-changing nature of a mission trip. The last one I read
was not sarcastic at all but incredibly scathing. The author of this one must
have been really hurt at some point and is still holding some resentment.
Here’s the tough part. I agree with the sentiment, if not
the tone, of many of these writings.
I agree that in many cases damage and backward progress are
the main effects of short-term missions. I agree that there is often a lack of
consideration of the long-term impact of a short-term trip. And, I agree that
many times these trips do more to stroke the ego and create a less then
completely accurate impression of the participants, both to themselves and
there facebook friends.
However, I also know that I have been shaped and molded by
my experiences in missions and my worldview and understanding have grown and
stretched because I had opportunities to participate in these trips. I know
that I have been humbled, educated, inspired and encouraged by my interactions
with people who live life in circumstances much different from my own. I know
that those are all impacts on me and not on those I “went to serve”. So…
For whatever its worth, here is my two cents on “mission
trips”. We should keep doing them. Maybe we can re-name them and do them
differently though. Maybe we can call them “trips” and we can go places and
learn about people and learn from them and maybe, if we need to do work, work together
to look for solutions to problems. Maybe sending rich kids to see how bad poor
kids have it so they can appreciate all their stuff is just gross and maybe we
could avoid posting pictures that make us rich kids look like we’re super
heroes and super people and maybe we can just love and serve because that’s what
Jesus did and its what he told us we should do too (remember that washing feet
thing? Jesus didn’t take a selfie while he was down there even though it would have made for a good one.)
Here’s the other conflicting thing: I’m here, in east
Africa, as a white westerner, with no expertise, limited education and little of value to offer but with a strong conviction that this is a good
place for me to be, maybe even the best place, that God is ok with me and my
family being here and pleased and could make something good of it, for the benefit
of people He loves.
Truth be told, I have days where I wonder if I’m here
because I love Jesus and want to love people or if its something else like my
ego or self-righteousness or to get great profile pics. I really wrestle with
it. I don’t know what the “best approach to missions” is or the absolute best
way we can serve people. I don’t know if it wouldn’t
be best if we all just stayed where we where born and did our loving God and
people from there. I trust Him though, and I trust that He’s the one that puts urges,
desires, dreams and passions on all of our hearts and that some of those cause
some of us to go to different places. So maybe all of this is ok. Maybe the
biggest thing, the things that matter most are our posture and ours hearts.
I could be wrong though…
Either way, please don’t stop supporting us!(again, winking emoji)
Well… That was cathartic. Thanks for coming along with me on that little train-of-thought ride. It was healthy for me at least.
Here’s what I was supposed to put on the blog today. Enjoy some pictures that might make us look a little too much like White Savior Barbie (Lord, help us! Closed eyes, smiling emoji):
I've been spending more and more time in a village called Lawmbogo. This is where we'll be getting to know people and working together on various projects. (I need to write a post specifically about this. Coming soon...) This past Saturday the whole family went out and we spent some time playing and some time working.
Ellie wasn't sure about all the attention initially but, as usual, she warmed up pretty quick. |
Izaac was also a bit uncomfortable but he found a way to rise above it |
Now some work- We needed to modify the water tank stands a little before they could be set up. Again, I need to elaborate- another post. |
It was medical clinic day so Christina helped take blood pressures for a while |
Also, Ellie walked a goat |
Thank you so much for sharing. I also read the White Savior Barbie post, and while laughing at its wit and ingenuity, I was afraid I was only reading about myself. In Nicaragua I've tried to take fewer selfies as to not make myself look like a hero or a tourist. Plus, I wrongfully judge all the one - week long missionaries who come here all the time. But how do I know what's going on in their hearts? I'm trying to trust that God has a purpose for sending each person on a missions trip - but I do like your idea of changing how those trips look.
ReplyDelete